We like to ridicule some ‘homerific’ broadcast coverage of NHL teams. NESN and Leafs TV are two of the worst offenders. But in a category all by themselves is RDS. While NESN may present coverage of the game heavily slanted towards the Bruins, RDS warps their broadcast in favor of certain players and against others. We all know who they are.
Golden boy Guillaume Latendresse was applauded by RDS last game for having gone 31 periods without a penalty. Apparently this was more important for us to know than the fact that Latendresse had only scored one goal in 19 games (20 after tonight’s game).
Tonight, Francois Gagnon presented a chart comparing Marc-Andre Bergeron with Andrei Markov. Outrageous? Apparently not to RDS.
For fairness, here it is:
(These are post lockout numbers.)
| Bergeron | Markov | ||||
| Goals | 52 | 44 | |||
| Power play goals | 35 | 28 | |||
| Power play points | 77 | 127 | |||
| Power play points/5 on 5 points | 57% | 58.50% | |||
Statistics buffs will know that if one selects carefully and narrowly enough, they can make an argument for almost any case.
Gagnon offered the disclaimer that some statistics can be deceiving. No kidding. Like these ones? In that case, why air them?
Why would Gagnon select a narrow range of statistics and present them as if they had meaning, if not to deceive a viewing audience? What purpose did this comparison serve?
Is Gagnon naive enough to not realize that he is only fueling the extreme and bigoted views of the disciples of Bob Sirois?
Does Gagnon not realize that Markov is one of the top five defenseman in the league? Does he not recall that 30 NHL teams passed on offering Bergeron a contract during free agency? Has he forgotten that the only reason that Bergeron is employed by the Canadiens is that they lost two defenseman to injury?
Perhaps he does remember all of these facts, and it was just all in good fun. Really?
For those who like comedy with their hockey, be sure to tune in next game as RDS features Gagnon’s comparison of Patrick Traverse to Doug Harvey.
I jest. They wouldn’t. Would they? Well up to tonight, I would have never imagined that even RDS would attempt to make a comparison between Bergeron and Markov.